From the moment I opened The Sweet Melissa Baking Book, I knew my relationship with this cookbook would be different. First, lots of her recipes appealed to my sense of taste immediately. That doesn't always happen. Like that Magnolia book? Eh. I opened, I browsed, and I never made the first thing from the book because while the products looked appealing, their flavor combinations were short of interesting me.
Another aspect to my fondness for Sweet Melissa is the book's design. The cover art is delicious. Its typography is inviting and I love the honey bees buzzing around the page. There are at least six or eight glossy pages of photos showing off the dishes with delightful styling.
And every time I think about the book, that line from the Allman Brothers tune haunts me. I'm hearing it in my head. Will have to get out my Allman Brothers greatest hits CD and listen to it in the kitchen. But hey, what is more appropriate in a southern kitchen than listening to the Allman Brothers? Okay, I can name at least a dozen other good old southern fried rockers or creoles or folkies or bluegrass or blues people to listen to in the kitchen. But it's Allman Brothers in honor of Sweet Melissa.
As a huge fan of cooking with Guinness, I stopped at the Guinness Gingerbread, and it was the first recipe I tried. Loved that it uses white pepper and a generous amount of ginger. There's also dutch process cocoa, which I found unusual, because my favorite gingerbread recipe, circa 1934 from the only cookbook my Mamaw Lestie owned and cooked from certainly doesn't put that much ginger in there or any white pepper at all in there.
For at least two weeks now I've hoped for the energy to get in the kitchen and cook. My health has been iffy. Nothing serious, just dead dog tired all the time, and so lounging on the couch reading or knitting appeals to me much more than serious work in the kitchen. Anyway, I worked through my tiredness, donned a new fancy Anthropologie apron I bought in Seattle or Philadelphia, and turned to the recipe.
I had all the ingredients! I bought fresh eggs and a package of dark brown sugar at the store in advance. I was ready. I preheated the oven. I buttered and floured my square pan. But it wasn't the 9 x 9 x 2 that Melissa Murphy indicated. I wasn't about to go out and buy one. I was ready to bake. And I wondered what kind of difference it made in the end.
It didn't. The 8 x 8 x 2 pan I had on hand, or in cupboard, worked fine. It worked perfectly.
Threw all the dry ingredients together into a bowl and then read that I should SIFT. So I sifted. That wasn't a major deal. I love to sift, actually, it so throws me back to my childhood and cooking with Mamaw because she almost always had something for me to sift. And I have an old-fashioned sifter like hers, though not hers.
Had to use a brand of molasses I wasn't thrilled with. But since I don't keep it on hand, I used what I had, and it did the trick. Ian spied the bowl later and asked what I made with chocolate in it. I suggested that what he thought was chocolate was actually molasses.
Then it baked for 50-60 minutes. At 48 minutes I inserted the wooden end of a matchstick into the cake and nothing came off. Yeah, I looked around for toothpicks. This is not the first time I've used a matchstick in a pinch. Ian didn't find the toothpicks, either, and so he pulled the plastic off a new box of matches and handed me one.
I cut the Guinness Gingerbread into 9 pieces and put two on two plates for our dessert. It was thick, dense, and could have supported the weight of a can of soup, no doubt. But I didn't try that.
We dug into our pieces and I was disappointed. It was dry, heavy, almost like a brownie, but not even a moist brownie. It reminded me of a bad batch of brownies I made for a boyfriend when I was 15. Ian liked it, liked the flavor. I did too, though. But I needed a glass of milk to dip it into. Then I said, "Gosh if the recipe had oil or butter in it, it'd be good." Got out the book again, turned to the page, and there, at the bottom, it lists cup of oil.
My mise en place is never in place, and somehow I missed that last, that vital ingredient. I decided to throw out that batch and try again.
If you'd like a copy of Sweet Melissa, let me know by leaving a comment and I'll select someone, if there's more than one, to send the book to. It's too good a book not to share it. I feel really selfish by keeping it all to myself.