I made two key lime pies the other day; one to keep and one to give away. Can't make just one, despite the recipe declaring that it yields one 9-inch pie. That has never been the case.
Before coconut cream pie usurped it from it's number one slot as my favorite pie, key lime pie was the be-all, end-all for me. The first time I ate key lime pie was in the summer of 1988 in Hilton Head. Harbortown, or nearby, as I recollect. I loved it. Don't know how I never had any before then. But from then on, I was on a quest to eat the best key lime pie. I always ordered it if it was on a menu.
And I learned to critique key lime pie after much exposure to the dessert. Was it too sweet? Too sour? Not sour enough? And usually there was a problem with it's color. I remember hearing that key lime pie should be yellow, never green, from Meryl Streep's character in Heartburn. So that was always a criteria as well. I haven't sone on a similar quest for the best coconut cream pie recipe. I'm content to eat it at Jane's Lunchbox since the place that serves the best coconut cream pie ever closed up shop last month, that being the much-missed Starving Artist of Abingdon, Virgina.
Here's the recipe. I stopped looking for other recipes once I found this one because it tasted perfect:
Crust:
1 1/2 cups of crushed ginger crisp cookies
1/3 cup melted butter (or margarine if you're into that)
1/4 cup granulated sugar
Filling:
2 14 oz. cans of condensed milk
1 cup of key lime juice
5 egg yolks
key lime zest ( you determine the amount, between 1-4 limes)
1 pint of heavy cream, whipped.
Preheat over to 350 F.
Start with the crust. Put crumbs and sugar in a bowl. Add melted butter. When well-mixed, squish into your pie pan, covering the bottom and sides. Pop pie crusts into the oven for 8 minutes. You can place a smaller pie pan on top of crust to give it more shape if you desire. Remove from oven and let cool.
If you make two pies be sure to do this crust part twice; once for each pie.
Whip heavy cream. Add other ingredients in any order you choose. I've found that the zest is tricky to add. It clings to my mixer's beater and doesn't get incorporated into the filling. this problem came to light while I cleaned the beater with my tongue.
You may discover that you have far too much filling for just one pie. Do with it what you will. That's why I make a second pie crust. I'm not skilled enough to understand how to divide the recipe. But, I think that my problem stems from too much whipping of the heavy cream.
Pour filling into pie crust and stick it in your oven to bake, still at 350 F, for another 8 minutes. Remove from oven. Let cool. Then freeze/chill. When ready to serve, top with non-dairy topping, or
whipped cream and garnish with sliced limes.
Wow. A discovery. This recipe came from Key Lime Cooking, a small-press published cookbook I picked up maybe ten years ago on on of our trips to Florida.

This recipe is called Joe's Stone Crab Key Lime Pie. It's title indicates that it was created by a restaurant, one I've not been to. Online I googled Joe's Stone Crab, found a website, and a recipe. So, it seems to me that the recipe I have in the cookbook was incorrect. And this may explain the reason for my two pie quandary.
Here's the real recipe (note the quantity of ingredients):
Graham Cracker Crust
1 wax paper-wrapped package graham crackers (1/3 of a pound box) or 1 cup, 2 1/2 tbsp graham cracker crumbs
5 tbsp melted unsalted butter
1/3 cup sugar
Filling
3 Egg yolks
1 1/2 tsp Grated zest of 2 limes
1 14-ounce can sweetened condensed milk
2/3 cup freshly squeezed lime juice
Topping
1 cup heavy or whipped cream, chilled
1 tbsp confectioners sugar
For the graham cracker crust:
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F. Butter a 9-inch pie pan. Break up the graham crackers; place in a food processor and process to crumbs. (If you don't have a food processor, place the crackers in a large plastic bag; seal and then crush the crackers with a rolling pin.) Add the melted butter and sugar and pulse or stir until combined. Press the mixture into the bottom and sides of the pie pan, forming a neat border around the edge. Bake the crust until set and golden, 8 minutes. Set aside on a wire rack; leave the oven on.
For the filing:
Meanwhile, in an electric mixer with the wire whisk attachment, beat the egg yolks and lime zest at high speed until very fluffy, about 5 minutes. Gradually add the condensed milk and continue to beat until thick, 3 or 4 minutes longer. Lower the mixer speed and slowly add the lime juice, mixing just until combined, no longer. Pour the mixture into the crust. Bake for 10 minutes or until the filling has just set. Cool on a wire rack, then refrigerate. Freeze for 15 to 20 minutes before serving.
For the topping:
Whip the cream and the confectioners' sugar until nearly stiff. Cut the pie in wedges and serve very cold, topping each wedge with a large dollop of whipped cream.
I was duped. I followed a wrong recipe for 5 or 10 years. Now I have to decide whether to try the real Joe's Stone Crab key lime pie recipe or stick with mine. Not making two pies would be a relief. But, I hate not to have one to nibble when I give the other away. Usually my father-in-law gets the other pie. It's my way of thanking him for the help he gives us with our spaniels when we're both out of town for short lengths of time.
There were two pies. I tried to do the whipping cream topping, which I normally don't do. But there was user malfunction. I whipped the cream too long, too hard? It came out grainy. And the other whipped cream was ruined beyond use. I've got to return to whipped dream school. I garnished it with sliced limes and took it over to my brother-in-laws' home. Family from Ohio was in town for the races (NASCAR at Bristol, Tn.) and we met to eat pizza, and fabulous potato salad (Dorothy's recipe that I'm supposed to get a copy of), and my pie.
Every five minutes someone asked "Did you make this?" I guess it was that good. And they should know by now that I don't bring store-bought items to any family gathering. I rarely do store-bought at all.